Woman Browsing a Website for Car Sales on a Laptop

How to Spot a Good Deal When Buying a Used Car Online: 7 Telltale Signs

Buying a car online is easier than ever, but convenience comes with risks. Scams, misrepresented listings, and vague histories can all turn a good deal into a costly mistake. That’s why it’s crucial to learn how to evaluate a used car listing like a pro. In this guide, we’ll walk through seven telltale signs that you’re looking at a trustworthy deal and how to avoid the red flags. Whether new to online car shopping or ready to upgrade, these used car buying tips for 2025 will help you shop smart and stay protected.

Ready to find your next ride? Browse our full selection of new inventory online at Get a Car USA and enjoy a no-pressure, streamlined shopping experience. Whether you’re in Chicago, IL or nearby in Romeoville, Highland, Plainfield, or Bolingbrook, start your search now and discover how simple it is to find the right car at the right price with Get a Car USA.

Why It’s Crucial to Be Cautious Online

Buying a used car online offers convenience, broader inventory access, and the ability to shop without the pressure of a dealership sales floor. However, it also limits your ability to inspect the vehicle in person before purchase, increasing the potential for scams or misrepresented listings. According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), fraudulent online vehicle sales remain a significant concern, often involving fake listings or sellers requesting payments through wire transfers or gift cards, methods that are difficult to trace or reverse.

Given these risks, it’s critical to learn how to buy a used car online safely by recognizing the signs of a legitimate deal, using verified platforms like Get a Car USA, and leveraging tools like vehicle history reports, escrow services, and third-party inspections to protect your investment.

1. Detailed and Consistent Descriptions

A well-written listing is your first clue. Look for vehicle descriptions that include:

  • Precise trim level and features (e.g., “2021 Toyota Camry XSE, leather seats, adaptive cruise control”)
  • Accurate mileage
  • Known history (number of owners, accident records, title status)

Watch out for overly general terms like “runs great,” “like new,” or “must see.” These can sometimes mask issues or avoid specifics. A good listing tells a story, and good sellers are upfront.

2. Clear, High-Quality, and Consistent Photos

Photos should show the car from every angle: front, back, both sides, interior, odometer, and engine. Make sure:

  • Backgrounds are consistent (all photos taken in the same location)
  • Lighting is natural and nothing is overly filtered or edited
  • Close-ups include wear and tear (if any)

Inconsistent photos (e.g., one taken in winter, another in summer) can suggest the seller is using stock images or borrowed photos, which is a red flag in online used car listings.

3. Verified Maintenance Records and Ownership History

Transparency in service history is a significant plus. Look for listings that:

  • Include service dates and mileage intervals
  • Show oil changes, tire rotations, brake inspections, and major repairs
  • Mention if work was done at a dealership or certified shop

Use services like CARFAX or AutoCheck to verify the car’s VIN and match records to the seller’s claims.

4. A Reasonable, Market-Adjusted Price

If the price seems too good to be true, it probably is. Compare the listing against prices on sites like Kelley Blue Book (KBB), Edmunds, or NADA Guides to ensure the value matches the vehicle’s:

  • Mileage
  • Year
  • Trim level
  • Condition

Avoid listings where the seller pushes for fast decisions or gives vague justifications for significant discounts—those tactics are commonly used in scams.

5. Sellers Who Offer Virtual Walkthroughs or Inspections

Good sellers are willing to let you look under the hood, virtually. Ask for:

  • A live video tour via FaceTime, Zoom, or WhatsApp
  • Videos of the startup, engine sound, and dashboard alerts
  • Third-party inspections by companies like LemonSquad or YourMechanic

If a seller refuses a remote inspection or dodges questions, move on. It’s among the most common warning signs in used car buying tips in 2025.

6. Shop and Sell Through Trusted Platforms Like Get a Car USA

Choosing the right platform is everything when buying or selling a vehicle online. Get a Car USA is a reliable, user-friendly destination for new and used car shoppers. With built-in tools to view vehicle details and access important ownership information, it’s designed to make your car shopping experience simple and secure.

Every listing on Get a Car USA is carefully reviewed to help reduce the risk of scams, and you can browse with confidence knowing the site prioritizes transparency and customer protection.

Whether you’re selling your current car or searching for your next ride, Get a Car USA streamlines the process with features like price comparison tools, vehicle history access, and responsive customer support. Avoid risky peer-to-peer transactions on less secure marketplaces—Get a Car USA makes it easier to find verified listings, fair pricing, and peace of mind from start to finish.

7. Look for Transparent Listing Features and Vehicle History Access

A trustworthy listing goes beyond just a photo and a price tag. On Get a Car USA, each listing is designed to give you the information you need upfront, like vehicle specs, trim levels, mileage, and available history reports, so you can make confident comparisons without guesswork.

Transparency in online listings reduces the risk of surprises and empowers smarter decision-making.

Pay attention to listings that clearly outline ownership history, accident reports, and service records. Platforms like Get a Car USA are built to help shoppers evaluate condition and value quickly, eliminating the need to dig through vague or incomplete descriptions. The more detail you can access from the start, the easier it is to determine whether a deal is worth pursuing.

Final Thoughts: Trust the Signs and Shop Smart

When it comes to how to buy a used car online safely, it’s not just about the vehicle—it’s about choosing the right platform, reviewing the listing details, and using the right tools to verify the deal.

At Get a Car USA, we make it easier to spot the signs of a smart purchase by offering transparent listings, vehicle insights, and intuitive search tools that help you shop with confidence. These seven telltale signs are your guide to navigating the online marketplace and finding real value. Combine your instincts with trusted resources like CARFAX, Kelley Blue Book, and third-party inspection services to make your next used car purchase secure, simple, and stress-free.